Friday, April 11, 2008

Mike Gravel: Behind the Rhetoric

On Wednesday, April 9th, the Penn Libertarian Association and the Penn Democrats co-hosted former Senator Mike Gravel to speak at Houston Hall. Senator Gravel has been the center of controversy ever since his decision to register with the Libertarian Party and seek the party’s presidential nomination. The Penn Libertarians and newly formed Philadelphia Forum for Freedom had a very strong showing at the event.

I want to take a moment to summarize my thoughts after this event as it helped clarify Senator Gravel’s positions for me and why he has made such a contentious move. He was a surprisingly powerful speaker that during Q&A was not only engaging, but persuasive. However, when you look past the rhetoric and the traditional maneuverings of an experienced politician, his claims to always being a “libertarian” don’t hold much water.

When pressed on how his positions with universal healthcare and government education fit in with a libertarian philosophy, Gravel was at the height of his political back and forth. On the issue of government education, Gravel argued against financing it with the property tax. He asked, how can impoverished neighborhoods be expected to fund schools from taxes in their area and compete with rich neighborhoods whose schools have more money from having wealthier individuals? Somehow, Gravel was trying to argue that a Robin Hood tax scheme was more libertarian than the current system. Great liberal ideas, but not libertarian.

On his support for universal healthcare, Gravel dodged the issue entirely. He spoke nothing of the government’s intrusion into private lives and mandatory support for the healthcare of all. Rather, he attempted to use his support for a national retail sales tax as the solution. His answer was more of an explanation as to how universal healthcare was a viable plan under his proposal rather than the merits of it being justified under libertarian doctrine.

What about that line he used to leave the Democratic Party, that it was “no longer the party of FDR?” When the PLA Treasurer, Josh Warren, pressed him on this, Gravel gave perhaps his most outrageous answer of the night. “FDR at least tried.” For Gravel, being a libertarian means that it’s OK for politicians to intervene in the economy, destroy the free market and take the U.S. to war just to “try” to do the right thing. Under this logic, one wonders why the current Bush is not his favorite President, because he has certainly tried many remedies to problems during his administration.

It was as though the Fair Tax allowed him to evade responsibility for any government policy. He seemed to think that if we just impose a sales tax, then the government has the right do whatever it wants because it acquires its revenue in a fairer way.

At one point during his speech, Gravel said “clichés don’t carry the day in any of this”, a consistent philosophy does. I cannot more heartily agree with him here. Gravel is filled with the right rhetoric of individual responsibility when he needs to, but he lacks the substantive positions to actually make him a libertarian. While he wears his sheep clothing most of the time, he became sloppy by the end of his speech: “I want capitalism. I want freedom to force competition.” Capitalism 101: force and capitalism contradict one another.

I respect Gravel for running for the LP nomination, but there should be no debate about whether he is a true libertarian or a liberal Democrat who is angry that he, personally, was not given the airtime he wanted. He even said so in his opening remarks, lamenting how he would only receive 4 minutes during the Democratic debates because Obama and Hillary were the chosen candidates. I am glad he takes the LP seriously enough to run for its nomination. But I will be severely disappointed if the LP gives him serious consideration as the presidential candidate.

Monday, April 7, 2008

Upcoming Philadelphia-area Freedom Events

Several members of the Philadelphia Forum for Freedom look on as the Constitution is ratified by the founding members of the Penn Libertarian Association. All members in attendance from Drexel, Temple, and Penn signed the constitution.












1. Penn Libertarians fundraiser- "Take a Shot for Liberty" shot glasses

Sold on Locust walk by the compass Tuesday-Thursday afternoon. $3 each or 2 for $5.

2. Former Democratic Senator and current presidential candidate Mike Gravel

Co-sponsored by the Penn Libertarians and the Penn Democrats, Gravel will be speaking at Penn in Houston Hall 223 to discuss, among other things, his controversial switch to the Libertarian Party on Wednesday April 9 @ 7PM.

3. Penn Libertarians Present: An Evening With the Cato Institute's Senior Editor, Gene Healy

Gene Healy will be giving a speach on his latest book, "The Cult of the Presidency: America's Dangerous Devotion to Executive Power," on Wednesday April 16th @ 7PM in Steinberg-Dietrich Hall 209. There will be a Q&A session followed by autograph signings of the book after the speech as well.

4. Drexel's Student Liberty Front is hosting the event "Who Killed the Constitution?"

Martyn Babitz, Esq., author of "The Illusion of Freedom: How to Restore the True Constitution and Reclaim Liberty Now," will be speaking at Drexel's Bossone Auditorium on Tuesday, April 22nd from 7-9 PM.

Although the school year is winding down, the next couple of weeks will be busy ones for the local libertarian movement, making it the perfect time to learn more about what we are about.

Sunday, April 6, 2008

Philadelphia Forum for Freedom Conference a Success!

On Saturday, April 5, the first annual Philadelphia Forum for Freedom Conference was held at the University of Pennsylvania. Everyone in attendance agreed it was a tremendous success. Eighteen students from the University of Pennsylvania Libertarian Association, the Drexel Student Liberty Front and the Temple Libertarians were in attendance. Participants talked about effective means of changing society to become freer and best practices for student organizations.

The final action of the conference, though, was the signing of the Constitution of the Philadelphia Forum for Freedom. While intense discussion and debate was held regarding the finer points of the mission statement and veto power of member organizations, all participants signed the Constitution, establishing the Philadelphia Forum for Freedom. The organization will be primarily run by an executive board that is composed of one representative from each member student organization. Three executive board members will be recognized as the President, Vice President of Outreach and Vice President of Logistics and Finance (this will currently be every executive board member since there are three organizations in the PFF, but this will change as more organizations are added). The PFF's activities will include an annual conference, a leadership retreat for all executive board members of the individual student groups, and providing outreach to new schools to help start student organizations dedicated to freedom.

Thank you to everyone who participated for making it a truly amazing conference!

If you would like to learn more about the Philadelphia Forum for Freedom or get involved, please email me at amccobin@sas.upenn.edu.

Thursday, April 3, 2008

You Can't Blame Earmarks for Everything

Earmarks this fiscal year: Approximately $18 billion
Budget this fiscal year: $3 Trillion

Penn received 160k from earmarks this year. In 2005, Penn received over $471 million from the National Institutes of Health.

Now if we only get angry about the earmarks as "conservatives" seem to do, then we miss the more important picture. Senator McCain has been calling him self a fiscal conservative and claims he will cut spending. But, earmarks have been his main target.

Right now I am concerned with our $9 trillion debt. Doing away with these annoying earmarks will no hardly put a dent in that number.

Wednesday, April 2, 2008

Where's McCain?

Since all of the other major players have dropped from the race (or minimally the media radar- sorry Ron Paul), John McCain is harder to find than a lone man with a white striped shirt in a large crowd. While in the long run it may prove to be a benefit to sit back and watch Hillary and Obama take each other down, the fundraising capabilities of each of these candidates cannot be denied. So while the Democrats are traversing the country raising money and promising to spend even more, McCain is telling everyone his life story, a story that, over so many years, must be long and drawn out.
Although I would be perfectly happy watching any and all of these candidates self-destruct, I am wondering how well this strategy will pan out for McCain in the long run of the general election and why nobody from his campaign has remedied or addressed this point. Security in the Primary may feel good for immediate gratification, but I can't remember the last time I saw anything useful about McCain on the news.
Universal health care anyone?

Friday, March 28, 2008

The Polls are Open

Election fever has struck Pennsylvania. No, I'm not talking about the Democratic Primary. The Student government election started today. There are 73 students vying for 61 spots. Sadly, many students will vote for whoever has the cleverest sign on locust walk.

Yet, other students will vote for different reasons. Several student groups will send out an email with a list of endorsements. There is nothing wrong with that, but it really makes me wonder what is the role of our student government. When an email goes out saying, you should vote for x because he supports y (a non Penn related issue), I question the scope of student government.

Recently, the UA spent a session debating the Red Cross ban on blood donations from homosexuals. Sure, this ban affects many Penn students, but it is not directly related to Penn. The UA should not be the venue for that. The UA should only deal with issues within Penn or else we forget the point of our fellow representatives.

Currently student government seems like a waste of time, but I do thank them for bringing the NY Times.

So go exercise your voting powers today, because the other election coming up is going to be depressing.

Thursday, March 27, 2008

Mike Gravel, FDR, and the Libertarian Party

Mike Gravel has recently announced that he is no longer seeking the Democratic Nomination for the Presidency. He is now seeking the Libertarian Party's nomination for the Presidency.

In an email announcing his new presidential bid, he explained his rationale: "The fact is, the Democratic Party is no longer the party of FDR. It is a party that continues to sustain war, the military-industrial complex and imperialism -- all of which I find anathema to my views."

Where to begin? First off, the Libertarian Party was founded to oppose FDR'ism and all its evils. FDR's New Deal was the start of big government that the LP was founded to oppose. If it were not for the introduction of so many government-sponsored redistribution and economic intervention programs that came about from there, the LP may have never come about to challenge them. Beginning his candidacy for the LP nomination by invoking FDR is perhaps the best way to summarize the futility of this campaign.

Let me list just a few of Gravel’s positions that are inconsistent with the LP platform:

  • Universal health care
  • Government sponsored "[p]arent education" (I'm unsure what this entails, but I'm scared by it)
  • Universal pre-kindergarten
  • Maintaining social security
  • "[M]onitoring the flow of immigrants into our country"
  • "Parity in health insurance and access to specialized family health care services" (which I can only assume is government sponsored)
Second, I would say that the Democratic Party is more the party of FDR today than it was a decade ago. Many references are made to the expansion of government power intervening in peoples' lives. Hillary Clinton has even tried to contrast this election as Hoover v. Roosevelt Round 2. FDR was popular for his support of big government both domestically and abroad. The Democratic Party is doing the same thing today. Ultimately, this should indicate that Gravel is doubtfully seeking the nomination out of a principled belief in any philosophy or need for change, but rather is doing so for the sake of power and fame like most politicians.

But is there any silver lining to this dark cloud? Gravel has in the past spoke out in favor of Reason Magazine (which is very libertarian) and called himself libertarian (even though I disagree with this). He is a very strong social libertarian and he does support the Fair Tax. What's more, his decision to switch to the LP is an indication that the Party Party is growing significantly.

In the end, as a registered member of the Libertarian Party who cast his first vote for Michael Badnarik in 2004, my gut reaction is to feel insulted by Mr. Gravel’s actions. I am glad that politicians like Gravel take the LP seriously enough to seek its support. However, I would rather such support come from someone who has more in line with the LP’s platform than merely an opposition to Bush and Iraq. The onus is on Gravel to convince big "L" Libertarians like myself that we should take him seriously.

The Penn Dems are actually sponsoring a talk by Mike Gravel at Penn on April 9th . I for one plan to attend and ask this question: As a registered member of the Libertarian Party who plans to volunteer at the National LP Convention in Denver, I have to ask, why should I not consider your run for my Party to be a waste of my time?